
This is a film that drew me into its world like few films can. It is excellently directed, well-paced, and the acting is phenomenal. However, once the big mystery is revealed, the entire film unravels for me. Perhaps I would’ve loved the film more had it kept me guessing.
“Weapons” is directed by Zach Creeger and stars Julia Garner as Justine, a school teacher who comes in one day to find that all but one of her students have gone missing. What unfolds is a story about loss and grief as we see a community come to terms with the sudden and mysterious disappearance of their loved ones.
The film’s narrative is broken up into sections based on a character’s viewpoints. We see Justine’s perspective of the events surrounding the disappearance, the perspective of a father of one the missing children (Josh Brolin’s Archer), a cop (Alden Ehrenreich’s Paul), various other community members, and then through the perspective of Alex (played by Cary Christopher) who is the only kid that didn’t disappear from Justine’s classroom.
I was extremely engrossed while watching this film, but things kind of fall apart when we get to Alex’s perspective. The more I thought about this film, once I left the theater, the plot made less and less sense to the point of it being nonsensical. I’m usually the kind of person to give a film some grace when it comes to plot holes, but my issues with this film were just too big to ignore.
How in the world did the police officers not realize that all the kids were bee-lining to one house in the neighborhood? It took Josh Brolin not even a day to figure this out. How was the disappearance of these kids kept under wraps from the media and the rest of the world in this day and age of social media? Did no-one question why Alex’s parents looked like zombies or weren’t talking? Did no-one in the neighborhood find it suspicious that Alex was buying truck-loads of soup every day or that his house is covered in newspapers? The list goes on and on, and I vary on where I stand in terms of letting certain things slide, but the whole mystery that was building up seems silly in retrospect.
That being said, this is a film that I almost considered calling my favorite of the year. I loved how the story is told through a broken narrative where we shift perspectives and see the same events through different eyes. Zach Creeger knocked it out of the park with the direction of this film, and I loved how the film plays close to the chest for most of its duration.
While I wouldn’t necessarily call it an out and out horror film, it does a great job of encapsulating the horror of the unknown. There is wonderful shot of a door silently opening at night that beautifully showcases this sentiment, and there are numerous scenes like this that I will certainly come back to in the future. However, if you are the kind of person who really needs an ending to stick, then I don’t think this is the film for you. I appreciate how well-crafted the film is, and I thoroughly enjoyed the journey and would recommend it with a big caveat that you’ll probably need to leave some logic at the door.